332: Serena Kerrigan: What We Get Wrong About Confidence, Rejection, & Being “Too Much”

Listen on Apple Podcast | Listen on Spotify

#332: Serena Kerrigan built an entire brand around confidence. But after realizing that the larger-than-life “Serena F*cking Kerrigan”'s persona was also a way to protect herself, Serena is now redefining what confidence actually looks like. Serena joins Josie for an unfiltered conversation about modern dating, self-worth, and how to shift your focus from getting someone to choose you to learning how to choose for yourself. She explains why a crush might just be a lack of information, how fear of being “too much” shapes the way we show up in our careers and relationships, and how to tell the difference between settling and simply letting go of the superficial checklist. This conversation goes far beyond dating, Serena gets vulnerable about the insecurities underneath her famous confidence, what her healthy relationship taught her about herself, and why becoming more confident has actually meant becoming softer. Plus, she and Josie talk career audacity, getting comfortable with rejection, why women need to ask for what they want, and Serena’s philosophy that something is only “cringe” until it works.

You’ll learn:

How Serena's definition of confidence has changed
What a healthy relationship actually feels like
Why Serena believes “a crush is just a lack of information”
How to stop choosing people who aren’t choosing you
Serena’s rules for first dates, pursuit, situationships, and knowing when to move on
How to know whether you’re settling or simply dating a real human being with flaws
Why we should all stop trying to perform as the “cool girl”
The career mindset that helped Serena turn bold asks, rejection, and “cringe” ideas into major opportunities

CHAPTERS:

00:20 - Meet Serena Kerrigan, aka SFK
01:00 - The origin of “Serena F*king Kerrigan”
03:00 - Real confidence vs. performing confidence
05:00 - Becoming your own best friend
08:00 - Breaking the pattern of choosing unavailable men
11:00 - Why anxiety isn’t chemistry
13:00 - Handling rejection without losing your confidence
15:00 - What a healthy relationship teaches you about yourself
16:15 - Are you settling, or prioritizing what actually matters?
21:00 - The dating beliefs holding you back
23:15 - Why a crush is just a lack of information
24:15 - Escaping the “cool girl” trap
28:20 - Dating rules: first dates, effort, and letting him pursue you
33:00 - Are female friendships a green flag?
34:45 - Building the confidence to think bigger
38:00 - Creating opportunities by asking for what you want
43:00 - Vision boards and small steps toward your dream life
45:20 - Rapid fire: red flags, self-worth, and Serena’s must-read book